Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture

Agricultural Health

AgroAmerica: International animal health specialist, Patrick Buholzer, stresses that to ensure food security countries will need to adopt a new approach to foot and mouth disease

Tiempo de lectura: 3 mins.

During an interview on the Agro America program, aired on Brazil’s TV Agro channel, Patrick Buholzer, Executive Director of the TAFS Forum, discussed the need for a new approach to the viral disease. He also called for a shared global understanding of the problem.

Patrick Buholzer, Director Ejecutivo del TAFS Forum, organización internacional con sede en Suiza, dedicada a la investigación de enfermedades animales transmisibles y su relación con la seguridad alimentaria.

Brasilia, 11 July 2023 (IICA) – According equal status to countries whose livestock industry is free of foot and mouth disease, whether with or without vaccination, is urgently needed to bolster food security, provide greater stability to agricultural producers and to enhance animal welfare. Thus, the entire society stands to benefit.
 
This was the view expressed by Patrick Buholzer, Executive Director of the TAFS Forum, an international organization headquartered in Switzerland, which is involved in the research of transmissible animal diseases and their relationship to food security.
 
“Distinguishing between countries that are foot and mouth disease-free with or without vaccination made sense in the past. It is now time to recognize that the two statuses are equivalent, given the high quality of vaccines today, which, in combination with the very sophisticated and precise diagnostic methods developed in recent years, provide an excellent tool to contain the disease”, said Buholzer during an interview on the AgroAmerica program, aired on Brazil’s TV Agro Mais channel. He expounded on the need to adopt a new approach to the viral disease and called for a greater shared global understanding of the problem.
 
He stated that from the point of view of security and access to international meat markets, countries must prove that they are free of foot and mouth disease and that they have implemented a consistent surveillance system. However, whether this is with or without vaccination should be a secondary consideration.
 
The expert stressed that many South American countries have an excellent track record of quality and security in their livestock production, having achieved foot and mouth disease-free status with vaccination. “A case in point is Uruguay, whose products are exported to multiple international markets and are far from being considered risky but are recognized for their safety”.
 
Buholzer pointed out that recognizing the equivalence of both scenarios is advisable from a scientific and commercial point of view. “Although trade today places no restrictions on countries that vaccinate, it would ensure greater security if they were considered equal. It would also provide greater stability and predictability for livestock producers”, he stressed.
 
Buholzer emphasized that given the differences established today, incorrect incentives are applied, encouraging many countries to push for foot and mouth disease-free status without vaccination, often too hurriedly, which has potential risks. “The decision to end vaccination should be based on risk assessment, considering the local and regional epidemiological situation. It is risky to eliminate vaccination without a careful analysis, seeking to increase opportunities by accessing new markets”.
 
He also emphasized that this step would mean that there would be less culling of healthy animals, as there would be fewer foot and mouth disease outbreaks. “Slaughtering healthy animals is no longer acceptable for societies and we have proven this on various occasions”, he said.

Seminars in Asia

During the interview Buholzer spoke about a historic international seminar that was held recently in Seoul, South Korea, where important stakeholders were discussing the topic. The event captured the interest of various Asian countries, where consumption of animal protein is on the rise. Asia is the main purchaser of South American meat and sales are estimated to continue growing in the coming years.
 
“We had an excellent discussion in Seoul and the participants demonstrated tremendous commitment. Representatives from international organizations, the industrial sector and from vaccine and other animal health-related companies attended. It was a very open discussion”, he said, while indicating that TAFS plans to host two addition seminars in Thailand and Taiwan in the coming weeks.
 
Buholzer reported that the Asian countries outlined their position in terms of foot and mouth disease, which is quite different from in the Americas. “In Asia, the disease is still present in many countries. South Korea itself had an outbreak just a short time ago, which happily it was able to contain quickly. In contrast, most countries in South America have been foot and mouth disease-free with vaccination for many years. There have been no outbreaks in most South American countries for several years”.
 
He closed by saying that, “Vaccination is like an insurance policy and placing with or without vaccination status on the same footing would be beneficial to all. We keep repeating this and we are seeing the positive results. People understand that this is necessary from a scientific point of view and also to guarantee food security, at a time when the climate crisis is creating severe challenges for agrifood production”.
 
AgroAmérica is a program broadcast by the Brazilian TV channel AgroMais, owned by the Bandeirantes Communication Group and produced in partnership with the Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture (IICA).
 
The show covers current affairs in the agriculture and rural sector to promote the sharing of experiences and a discussion on challenges and opportunities in Latin America and the Caribbean.

More information:
Institutional Communication Division.
comunicacion.institucional@iica.int

Share

Related news​

San José, Costa Rica

June 5, 2025

At IICA, Costa Rican cacao producers are recognized for the excellence of their products and for their contribution to rural development and nutrition in the region

Experts analyzed 15 samples of cacao from various parts of the Central American country, with the five that received the highest scores then declared winners of the 2025 competition. The same five samples were sent to Rome, Italy, where they will represent Costa Rica in the international “Cacao of Excellence” competition, the stepping stone to the International Cocoa Awards.

Tiempo de lectura: 3mins

Turrialba, Costa Rica

June 3, 2025

On a study visit to Costa Rica, ministers of Agriculture, rural youth and women of the Eastern Caribbean were introduced to improved agricultural practices

The mission began with two days of activities at IICA Headquarters in San Jose, including meeting with the IICA Director General, Manuel Otero. The visitors then travelled to CATIE.

Tiempo de lectura: 3mins

San José, Costa Rica

June 2, 2025

Ibero-America sees biofuels as a solution to decarbonize the energy sector  

The annual meeting of the Ibero-American Association of Energy Regulators (ARIAE), held in San Jose and Guanacaste, Costa Rica, featured the II Entrepreneurial Forum, attracting 200 participants, including the Costa Rican Minister of Environment and Energy, the Executive Secretary of the Latin American Energy Organization (OLADE) and authorities of the Ibero-American General Secretariat (SEGIB); the XV Regular Annual Meeting of the ARIAE General Assembly, which was attended by 17 regulatory agencies of ARIAE; and the XXVI Annual Meeting of ARIAE Energy Regulators.

Tiempo de lectura: 3mins